The boots are definitely okay, comfortable, waterproof, etc. Very light, which makes a huge positive difference during marches; in the rain, the foot stays dry, and moisture wicking is also a plus. The only issue is that in freezing temperatures the boots do not perform well: the wicked-away sweat freezes on the material and the feet 'boil' inside, so frequent airing and changing socks helps. After 8 months, the boots were damaged through no fault of my own, but I reported the problem, received a positive resolution, and got them replaced with a new pair. From what I have noticed, this is just how these boots are, and they usually wear through in the same place. As long as the warranty is valid, there is nothing to worry about; after the warranty, you can always add some patches. Despite everything, I recommend them.